Is your class going through pencils like it's going out of style?  Is your supply of Ticonderogas running low? I've got a challenge for you and your class that will teach your students to value their materials while saving you money on pencils.  The Great Pencil Challenge has been a life saver in our classroom this year!  *This post contains affiliate links where I am compensated a small commission for sharing items with you.

I've always had two containers for pencils, one dull and one sharp.  At the end of the day, the 2 students who are in charge of sharpening pencils would do so.  Super easy.  This system has always worked…until this year with my sweet little group of students.  I've found that this group is going through so many pencils per week.  If they lose their pencil, they just grab another.  Break one…no problem, there's plenty more.  Enough was enough.  I had to do something because we were running very low on pencils and I was not going to buy anymore.

The Great Pencil Challenge

I had a few student helpers attach masking tape to the top of our pencils and number them.  I've got 24 students so we numbered them from 1-24 and included a few extra because #pencilsmaygetlost.

On Monday, all pencils were collected and I hid away our sharpening buckets in the cabinet.  My 2nd graders thought I lost my mind!  I brought everyone to the carpet and we made this chart together.  You can make the chart however you'd like.

Disclaimer: We are using classroom money as part of our economy unit.  I'm not charging real money because 1) that's illegal and 2) I'd lose my job!

Management Tips

• Throughout the day, do a Pencil Check.  I literally just say “Pencil Check” and they all hold up their pencils.  Super easy!  You can even reward a few students with an incentive.
• Decide how you want to handle dull pencils.  I don't love the option we're using because I don't like hearing the pencil sharpener during class time.  But, we currently have students give their pencil to the pencil sharpener job-person and she'll go sharpen it as long as it's not during direct instruction.
• Reward students who still have a working pencil at the end of the day or the end of the week.

Broken Pencils

It happens.  One of my scholars broke his pencil on the 2nd day of the Great Pencil Challenge! Said friend thought it would be a fabulous idea to hold his pencil perpendicular against his desk and lean really hard against it. #goodbyepencil I had to be consistent and use this little guy as an example for the rest of the class.  I'm proud to say we're about to start our 4th week of the Great Pencil Challenge and we haven't had any broken ones since.

Try it in your classroom and tag me on Instagram @easyteachingtools to share how it's going!
Want to see the Great Pencil Challenge in action?